Charleston Chapter – MOAA Charleston Chapter – MOAA
Charleston Chapter – MOAA Charleston Chapter – MOAA
Member Login    News    Support our Charities    Photos    Event Calendar      
Charleston Chapter – MOAA


Recent News:
(Published in last 30 days)


Charleston Chapter – MOAA
Date Posted:09/11/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Tricare Open Enrollment for 2020 Begins Soon

Date Posted:09/09/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
New App from VA Streamlines Veterans’ Resources to Enhance Their Care

Date Posted:09/06/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Lawmakers to VA: Provide Health Care to All Veterans Made Sick by Burn Pits

Date Posted:09/06/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Military folks, here are some expert tips on picking the right charity for your donations

Date Posted:08/29/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Some Children of US Troops Born Overseas Will No Longer Get Automatic American Citizenship

Date Posted:08/29/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Here's Who's Affected by New Citizenship Policy for Children of Troops Serving Overseas

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Key Pentagon Official Endorses Commissary Exchange Merger

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Millions of Veterans to Be Memorialized Online in VA Legacy Project

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
After Mandate from Congress, VA Opens Research Center for Burn Pit Related Illnesses

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Trump Signs Bill Protecting Disability Payments for Veterans Who Declare Bankruptcy

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Exchange Extends Online Shopping Pick Up Options

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
South Carolina State Veteran Benefits

Date Posted:08/28/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
VA secretary rejects Obama religious expression rules: 'They did not know the makeup of the force'

Date Posted:08/23/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Military Pharmacies May Change List of Free Over the Counter Drugs Offered

Date Posted:08/23/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Pentagon Rolls Out New Spouse Transition Program

Date Posted:08/13/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
New 'Bombshell' Legal Opinion Says Military Retirees Can't Be Court Martialed

Date Posted:08/13/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Ralph H. Johnson VA Medical Center

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Terminally Ill Military Kids Can Now Receive Both Treatment and Hospice

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
VA vision care

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Advocates plead to keep widow’s tax repeal in military policy measure

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Watch: TV News Keeps Fight to End Widows Tax in the Public Eye

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Pending law could help vets get treatment at the VA for toxic exposure

Date Posted:08/07/19
This Story Expires on: 11/30/19
Serving after service: How getting involved helped me overcome my fears and rediscover myself

Date Posted:08/06/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Pin Ups For Vets unveils 2020 calendar

Date Posted:08/06/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
The first underwater veterans memorial is open for divers

Date Posted:07/30/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Tricare Rates Increasing in 2020 for Reservists, Young Adults, Others

Date Posted:07/25/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Esper creates task force to deal with cancer causing chemicals on military installations

Date Posted:07/25/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Here’s how 3 million more people will get military shopping benefits

Date Posted:07/25/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Google Expands Support for Veterans Looking to Compete in Fast Paced Startups

Date Posted:07/25/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Bill to Increase Adaptive Housing Grants for Wounded Vets Passes House

Date Posted:07/25/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
New Law Will Allow Thousands More Veterans to Join American Legion

Date Posted:07/18/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
CHAMPVA Recipients Can Now Get Prescriptions Online from the VA

Date Posted:07/18/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
5 Entrepreneur Tips from 'Shark Tank' Navy SEAL

Date Posted:07/10/19
This Story Expires on: 09/29/19
Here's How Much the 'Salute to America' Flyovers Cost the Military

Date Posted:07/10/19
This Story Expires on: 09/29/19
VA Announces Delay in Processing Blue Water Vietnam Veterans' Claims

Date Posted:07/09/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
VA MISSION Act: Answers to the top five questions about urgent care

Date Posted:07/09/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
VA health care

Date Posted:07/09/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
Pentagon Delays Big Changes to Post 9/11 GI Bill Transfer Rules

Date Posted:07/05/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Vets, Troops Can Get Free Sports Gear for Their Kids. Here's How.

Date Posted:07/05/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
5 Threats to Your Military Transition and How to Reduce Them

Date Posted:07/05/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Spouse Professional License Reimbursement Now Offered by All 5 Services

Date Posted:07/05/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
How to Get Free Supplies to Ship Care Packages

Date Posted:07/03/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Disabled vets could see their student loan debts automatically erased

Date Posted:07/03/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
No Decision Yet From VA on New Agent Orange Presumptive Diseases

Date Posted:07/03/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Historic Million Veteran Study Could Lead to PTSD Research Breakthrough

Date Posted:07/03/19
This Story Expires on: 12/31/19
5 Ways to Break the Ice When Networking

Date Posted:07/03/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19
What About a Franchise? 4 Veteran Friendly Options

7 Affordable Ideas for Military Care Packages

Date Posted:06/29/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
TAP is getting a makeover this year. Here’s what you need to know.

Date Posted:06/27/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
After Decades of Fighting, the Blue Water Navy Benefits Bill Is Now a Law

Date Posted:06/22/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Free App Lets Troops Read to Their Kids at Home

Date Posted:06/12/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
The Meaning Behind the 13 Folds of Old Glory

Date Posted:06/10/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
The Warning Signs of Suicide and What to Do

Date Posted:06/04/19
This Story Expires on: 12/31/19
Ralph H. Johnson VA Medical Center

Date Posted:06/03/19
This Story Expires on: 11/16/19
Korean War Vets Eligible for Free Return Tour

Date Posted:03/31/19
This Story Expires on: 10/30/19
A robot reading your resume? 10 tips for vets to beat job screening software

Date Posted:03/27/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
South Carolina State Veteran Benefits

Date Posted:03/19/19
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Here's All the Government Programs that Help Vets with Jobs and Benefits

March 22 Luncheon Meeting

Date Posted:05/05/18
This Story Expires on: 09/30/19
Take the VA's New RAMP to a Faster Appeal Decision

Military Star Card Questions & Answers

US Air Force Museum to Mark 75th Anniversary of Japan Raid

Breaking News   
Register for News Story Emails

New 'Bombshell' Legal Opinion Says Military Retirees Can't Be Court Martialed
Posted on: 08/13/19
This Story Expires on: 10/31/19




A new legal opinion from the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals says court-martialing military retirees is unconstitutional -- and the reason concerns the issue of retirement pay.

Chief Judge Navy Capt. James Crisfield delivered the opinion last week, joined by Senior Judges Navy Capt. Marcus Fulton and Marine Col. Jonathan Hitesman. The decision was made as a result of an appeal from retired Chief Petty Officer Stephen Begani, who was court-martialed after leaving the Navy on charges of attempted sexual abuse of a child.

Begani was picked up by Naval Criminal Investigative Service agents on Aug. 5, 2017, a little over a month after he left active duty and was transferred to the Fleet Reserve. He was arrested when he arrived at a residence at Marine Corps Air Station Iwakuni, Japan, where he was employed as a contractor. Begani had been communicating with someone who he believed to be a 15-year-old girl, but who was actually an undercover NCIS agent.

He was sentenced to 18 months confinement and a bad-conduct discharge.

Begani was court-martialed because of a federal law that leaves some troops subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice long after they hang up the uniform. Marines and sailors who leave active duty after more than 20 years in uniform but less than 30 and who want to collect retiree pay move into the Fleet Reserve or Fleet Marine Corps Reserve.

There they receive what is essentially retainer pay and can be summoned back to active duty without their consent in the event of war or a national emergency. After 30 years of active or inactive service, retirees are then transferred to the Regular Retired List and they're no longer subject to the UCMJ.

None of this is true for retired reservists, though, which is why Crisfield argued in his written opinion that treating one group of retirees different than another is unconstitutional.

"Congress has determined that some, but not all, military retirees should remain subject to the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) while they are retired," Crisfield wrote. "... Accordingly, the sections of the UCMJ subjecting regular component retirees to UCMJ jurisdiction are unconstitutional."

Related: Supreme Court: Retirees Can Be Court-Martialed for Crimes Committed After Service

Zachary Spilman, a lawyer who specializes in military justice and the lead contributor to the military justice blog CAAFlog, where he first wrote about the decision, called the opinion "a bombshell."

"This is a huge deal," he said. "A court-martial for a retiree is very rare, but the threat of a court-martial is very real."

As Spilman noted in his Tuesday blog post on the decision, Begani did not challenge jurisdiction at trial, but he did challenge it on appeal. Begani argued that being subjected to the UCMJ as a retired regular component member while retired Navy Reserve members are not "violated the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause's guarantee of equal protection of the laws."

Navy Lt. Daniel Rosinski, who represented Begani, argued that there's no difference between a reservist retiree or one who left active duty. They're all out of uniform, none are subject to military duties on a day-to-day basis, and they can all be recalled to active duty, Rosinski said in his oral arguments. But a reserve retiree in Begani's case would have been tried as a civilian.

Since they're "similarly situated," Rosinski argued that active and Reserve military retirees should be treated no differently when it comes to UCMJ jurisdiction.

"There are good reasons to subject full-time active-duty personnel to military jurisdiction," Rosinski said. "They're performing military duties on a day-to-day basis and there's a compelling governmental interest in regulating their conduct.

"But there's not good reason to distinguish among those non-active-duty personnel -- active-duty retirees, retired reservists and selective reservists -- for purposes of court-martial jurisdiction," he added.

Spilman said that's where the judges' opinion -- which essentially agrees with Rosinski's point -- is flawed. The judges' opinion acknowledges that the retainer pay regular retirees like Begani receive come with the obligation that they'll "maintain readiness for active service in event of war or national emergency."

"That's hardly an insignificant obligation; maintaining readiness for active service -- while not a particular specific demand -- undoubtedly requires a person to remain ordered and disciplined, the maintenance of which is the very reason for a military justice system," Spilman wrote on Tuesday. "Furthermore, the federal courts have recognized that the Fleet Reserve was established for that specific purpose."

In a Thursday follow-up post, Spilman again reiterated that those like Begani who are in the Fleet Reserve or the Fleet Marine Corps Reserve receive retainer pay, which is different than retired pay, and that a member "must actually be in that status to get the money."

Spilman told Military.com on Thursday he believes there's "zero chance" the government will not ask the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals to reconsider its decision.

The U.S. Supreme Court earlier this year upheld the Defense Department's authority to prosecute military retirees for crimes they commit when it opted not to hear the case of retired Marine Staff Sgt. Steven Larrabee, who was convicted of sexually assaulting a bartender.

The Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals opinion could now affect other cases, Spilman said. That includes Larrabee's, who has taken his case to the U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C.

Stephen Vladeck, a professor at the University of Texas School of Law who represents Larrabee, has argued, like Rosinski that military retirees should not be subject to the UCMJ. He told Military.com in February when the Supreme Court declined to hear Larrabee's case that the idea that retirees could be pulled back into active duty was outdated.

"Increasingly, the function has been performed by reserves, not retirees," Vladeck said at the time.

Not everyone agreed, though. Retired Air Force Maj. Gen. Charles Dunlap, a professor at Duke University's law school, wrote in February that it's up to retirees who don't want to keep a relationship with the military to terminate their commission or request a discharge.

"As a retired service member subject to military jurisdiction, count me among those of my comrades-in-arms who believe it a small price to pay to maintain the connection with the armed forces," Dunlap wrote.

By Gina Harkins

Patricia Kime contributed to this report.



Return to News Stories
Charleston Chapter – MOAA
Charleston Chapter – MOAA

· Copyright ©2019 Charleston Chapter – MOAA P.O. Box 70421 Charleston SC 29415 ·
· Contact Charleston Chapter – MOAA · Editorial and Privacy Policy · Webmaster · Browser and Email Settings ·
· Website by VetVentures.org · VetVentures.org Disclaimer ·
V.8